A Gruesome Crime

On August 20, 1979, the peaceful community of Poughkeepsie, New York, was rocked by a horrific crime. Albert Fentress, a 37-year-old middle school teacher, brutally murdered 18-year-old Paul Masters, a local high school student. Masters had innocently wandered into Fentress’s backyard, where he was lured into the basement with beer. There, Fentress shot him twice in the head before engaging in acts of mutilation and cannibalism. The details of this gruesome crime sent shockwaves through the community and garnered national media attention.

The Insanity Defense

Following his arrest, Fentress claimed he was in a dissociative state during the murder. In 1980, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity, resulting in his confinement to a mental health facility rather than a prison. Over the next two decades, he underwent treatment, sparking ongoing debates about his potential release and the implications for public safety.

Controversial Release Decision

In April 1999, after 20 years in psychiatric care, a jury ruled that Fentress was no longer a danger to society, recommending his release. This decision ignited outrage among the public and local officials, including Governor George Pataki, who criticized the justice system for considering release for someone with such a violent past. The victim's family expressed deep concern, feeling that true justice had not been served.

Judicial Reversal and Ongoing Concerns

Despite the jury’s recommendation, a judge later overturned the decision, citing Fentress's continued mental health issues. Evaluations indicated that he still posed a potential risk, underscoring the complexities of balancing mental health treatment with community safety.

Broader Implications

The case of Albert Fentress raises significant questions about the intersections of criminal justice and mental health. As discussions about his future continue, the community remains vigilant, reflecting broader societal concerns about how we manage individuals who commit such heinous acts and the implications for public safety.

Best Wooded Area to Film a Horror Movie in the Hudson Valley

Ever wonder where the perfect woods in the Hudson Valley would be to film a scary movie in? Here are the best choices according to Hudson Vally residents:

Gallery Credit: Google Maps

More From 107.7 WGNA